71 Comments
User's avatar
Mary Robinette Kowal's avatar

An outline, a novel, and allllll the SFWA work. I've learned to make an X on finished tasks and a \ on tasks that I've touched. It allows me to feel like I am still making progress.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Oh I love the idea of indicating you’ve “touched” something—that’s definitely something I have a hard time with, layers of anxious inflammation building around even the idea of a task so that I don’t feel I *can* touch it. That mark looks like the lightest stroke of a finger along something. Thank you for that! & for all the wonderful work you’re doing!

Expand full comment
Steve Toase's avatar

My newsletter. It takes me about a day to write, but with starting back on Tuesday (Monday was a holiday in Bavaria), starting a new routine of breaking my writing day with a walk, and getting a book deal for my first short story collection, I’ve been a bit distracted.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Congratulations on the book deal Steve!!! That’s fantastic news!

Expand full comment
Steve Toase's avatar

Thank you!! It’s been a very good start to the year :)

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

Well, hi there, you two! Nice to see you here. Claire & Carlos have just convinced me to get started with my own newsletter on Substack, using Amal as a model - but now I see there's Steve as well! This is very cool. Kind of like your own personal Facebook page, yeah? (I wondered where you've all been hiding - now I know! Any advice?)

Expand full comment
M Frank's avatar

I started knitting a blanket! It’s much too big of a project to finishing RIGHT AWAY which is V good for me, but also itches like a healing scrape. It’s orange! And for my SIL! And I love it already!

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Ooh, cool! Are you using any particular pattern?

Expand full comment
Elisa Wiik's avatar

I worked on my PhD and started to code a dataset for a joint article. Both gloriously unfinished but I am satisfied with my progress!

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

WITNESSED & CHEERED! You are superb!

Expand full comment
Elisa Wiik's avatar

<3 <3 <3

Expand full comment
Filip Drnovsek Zorko's avatar

The story I'm working on for the Silk & Steel anthology. There was one (1) day of sunshine this week and I think it accounted for like 80% of the progress I made...

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

WITNESS YOU! So looking forward to that anthology!

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

I am so excited for that anthology! I'm trying to get something together to submit, but I mostly just want to read ALL THE STORIES.

Expand full comment
Ellen Kushner's avatar

I'm already halfway through mine - started it almost as soon as I got the offer. As a performer, for me there is something nourishing and compelling about knowing something is already accepted, and that people are enthusiastically waiting for it.

Expand full comment
Filip Drnovsek Zorko's avatar

I know that feeling! Sadly I have to take my chances in the slush pile - but hope springs eternal! (& regardless, I'm very excited to read your & everyone else's stories. :D)

Expand full comment
C. L. Polk's avatar

I handed in proposals for my next book, and not working on a novel feels like wandering aimlessly through a huge empty house. there should be something there - a beat up couch, even - but there isn't anything. So naturally I'm desperately sprouting story ideas that I'm not going to write.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

I love this notion that you're populating the huge empty house with sprouts. Make sure to give them lots of light & Water!

Expand full comment
C. L. Polk's avatar

it feels good, just coming up with these story ideas and writing down what i see in them. even if I don't write them at all, it feels good to come up with them.

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Where do you keep your story sprouts? Or do you keep them?

Expand full comment
C. L. Polk's avatar

I write them down in a file and organize it into the relevant folders in google docs!

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Ooh, google docs file is smart. I write mine into various notebooks or email them to myself but then anything specific ends up being impossible to find.

Expand full comment
KM Hammond's avatar

Desperately spouting story ideas ... so very relatable. :D

Expand full comment
C. L. Polk's avatar

it's fun, too!

Expand full comment
KM Hammond's avatar

I got part way through some novel revisions and some audio work. Still a long way to go, but I like this exercise in appreciating the steps along the way to completion. It's nice the stop and realize that the increments count, too. :)

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

They ABSOLUTELY DO, they do count, or rather they exist & we should count them, as they won't count themselves!

Expand full comment
Margo's avatar

Like, everything in my life?! I feel that everything I do is a work in progress. Including myself.

Expand full comment
Margo's avatar

And I totally relate the the feeling of not having done enough that I can point to and say “it is finished“.

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Ugh, I so relate to the work-unfinished thing. My solution right now is to just be more granular about my tasks so that I can point to the parts that I _did_ finish. I've built that into part of my week -- looking back at and giving myself credit for the things that I did -- because my tendency is to only look at the things I have left to do.

Anyway. I finished drafting chapter one of the heart novel I've been ruminating on for the better part of a year now. It's messy and needs work and (insert more qualifiers attached to that accomplishment), but it's on paper! And I'm so close to having a complete outline-y thing for a short story I'm working on.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

This is such a good approach, & something I strive to do -- that granular break-down. Good for you, creating systems to recognize & celebrate the increments!

Expand full comment
Alyshondra's avatar

HEART NOVEL I need to know more, novels of the heart are MY FAVORITE

Expand full comment
Alyshondra's avatar

Also, the recognition of what I did already SAVES ME, especially in the depressive winter months. I make did-do lists, and it’s much more heartening than an endless never finished to-do list. And I find myself doing more, because I want to write it down!

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Agreed! I do my workflow tracking in a Notion workspace and I have it set up like a Kanban board so I move cards from one column to the next. Even though scratching something off a list doesn't do anything for me, moving something from "Doing" to "Done" is something my brain really likes. Go figure. Then at the end of the week, I can look at my stack of "Done" cards and keep some perspective for when my brain wants to be like "you didn't do anything this week."

Expand full comment
Alyshondra's avatar

WHY BRAIN, I did so many things stop being a jerk!

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Oof, Alyshondra, I was literally trying to figure out how to craft the one liner for it today, which is an exercise I've never tried and is really. hard. Once I figure that out, I'll tell you. 😅

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Right now, I'm literally just flailing my arms around and saying unrelated words to people when they ask.

Expand full comment
Miri Baker's avatar

Slogging my way through dayjob tasks and wedding-dress tasks alike.

Expand full comment
C. S. E. Cooney's avatar

I keep working on my novella, but it’s like I’m always four scenes from the end. The last three work days I revised the same scene three times. But also each time, I learned something more about what the end will look like. Still, frustrating. Why can’t I write it and THEN see what it’s supposed to look like and then FIX it??? Am I skipping a step or adding it?

Also, dishes. Work unfinished. Even when you’ve just finished them.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

DISHES!!!! LAUNDRY!!! O for Anne Shirley's perspective on the matter!

Expand full comment
Max Kaehn's avatar

I work at a software company where every code check-in has to be reviewed by someone else, and there are lots of go-rounds on discussing design documents, so “incremental progress” is pretty much the default for me at work. I’m happy with the progress my team is making this week on our designs, and I’ve helped a couple of people solve obscure problems as well.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Tremendous! (I was about to say Well Done but that feels antithetical to the spirit of this enterprise!)

Expand full comment
Katie's avatar

Hey we work at the same software company! I actually really like this approach though, it keeps the demons of non-accomplishment at bay.

Expand full comment
Max Kaehn's avatar

In that case you may find go/mithriltabby to contain useful information. :-)

Expand full comment
Katie's avatar

This contains so! Much! Information!!

Expand full comment
TJ Radcliffe's avatar

Granularity is good, and can be refined beyond the task level. In my project management days I developed a system where tasks had a small number of stages: Not Started, Started, Partly Done, Half Done, Mostly Done, and Done. It's pretty easy to fool ourselves with abstract numerical estimates but a bit harder with these fairly intuitive categories. This system also had the advantage of giving a feeling of accomplishment, of finishing something, as things were moved from one stage to the next.

For me, this week's unfinishment (maybe this year's unfinishment) is a weird long narrative blank verse thing (likely to run maybe 3000-5000 lines, currently at about 1200) that's a riff on Romeo and Juliet, which seemed like a good idea at the time.

The thing that writing "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and Ham" taught me is that my narrative poetry process is pretty prose-like: initial draft is just getting it all splatted out on the page, then rework and rework and rework until it has some shape and sense. I used to be much more of a "perfected page" poet, I think in part because it helped me feel like I was "finishing" things.

Expand full comment
Nino Cipri's avatar

Naruto fanfiction. Because sometimes you just gotta write about ninjas and feelings and, uh, the long term effects of sending children into war

Expand full comment
Katie's avatar

I’m fighting a round with pneumonia and haven’t been to work a single day this week. It frustrates me, but also I have to be kind to myself and understand that I couldn’t work right now anyway.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

It sounds like you’ve been working on rest & recovery, extremely important things!! Champion!

Expand full comment
wjr's avatar

I've been doing kind of the opposite: working on multiple projects but never deeming any of them as ready for other people to start using. There's always one more feature I could add, one more way in which I'm not totally sure performance will 100% match the system it's replacing, and so on. I end up putting these almost-complete projects aside as the last bit of work is always the most annoying... but this lack of completion and delivery has been wearing me down so this week I'm trying to go back to a bunch of projects in this "not quite ready to ship" state and closing the final gaps.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Ahh this sounds kind of exciting to me too—all this structural work done, & you can see where the gaps & final pieces fit together. Witness you!

Expand full comment
wjr's avatar

Yeah, it's going to be great once it's all launched and people are using it and being happy with the new functionality! I just have to get it over the barrier in my head of "it's not perfect ENOUGH".

Expand full comment
Ruth Temple's avatar

I came here from a mutual FB friend; What I worked on, unfinished, this week, is the second in what will unfold somehow as a series of postcard-sized handwoven tapestries as diary, begun this year. Last week's looks like the fog rolling up and nibbling on the ridgeline of the coastal mountains from where I live in San Jose, CA; this week's is much more abstract and has fire season thoughts & colors, both in Northern California and in Australia.

Expand full comment
Dave Hogg's avatar

The second piece of fanfic I've ever started. It's a detective story set in the Star Wars universe where the detective is a Hutt and his assistant is a protocol droid. There will be cameos.

(The first one was how John Wilkes Booth used a hippo to assassinate Abraham Lincoln a month earlier than it happened in our timeline.)

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

A dissertation, a job application, taking down Christmas decorations, working on a story...feels like all I am is work unfinished these days. I definitely identify with finding it hard to let anything “count” till it’s done, so I really appreciate this thread.

Expand full comment
Vlad's avatar

I am literally trying to work on this this year! This week I have been working on saying "let's continue work on this project tomorrow!" When the clock rolls to 5-5.30

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

BEST OF VLADS, that's so good to hear!

Expand full comment
Vlad's avatar

YOU'RE the best! Good luck with valuing the awesome work you are doing, finished or not. :)

Expand full comment
Alyshondra's avatar

Two things: I am designing a cross stitch of some dear friend’s wedding vows, and am feeling the urge to FINISH, but I also want it to be *wonderful* and that works better with a little stepping away and percolating.

The other is an ongoing process of “what are the 5-7 things that are essences to my heart” (inspired by MRK). I know a few: serenity, novelty, creation, but what’s the right word to describe how I love helping folks be valued, seen, lifted up? (Kindness? Validation? Enliven? Nourish?) How about how much something is heightened by being shared? (Collaboration? Togetherness?) It’s SUCH an interesting exercise, and there process and introspection is certainly almost more valuable than the actual end result. (But I would love suggestions if anyone has any!)

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Ahh!! I love this idea of heart-essences—where did she write/talk about that?

It makes my heart so happy knowing you’re making more art, making the world more beautiful stitch by careful stitch.

Expand full comment
Mary Robinette Kowal's avatar

Crystal Hunt (from SiWC) turned me on to Laura Lavigne's happiness workshop, which is a fascinating thing. The Happiness Crash Course is free and only five minutes over three days.

She talks about essence vs. form in it. http://www.lauralavigne.com/happiness-crash-course.html

I'm taking the longer course now and it is giving me Much Too Think About.

Expand full comment
J.M. Coster's avatar

Both of those things are so beautiful! Your cross stitches are amazing! I love that idea -- the essences to your heart. That's so lovely a concept. Something to go ponder...

Expand full comment
Alyshondra's avatar

It is being surprisingly helpful in more way than I expected! It’s essentially a way to distill “what brings me joy”, so it helps me decide between options (stacking essences is better!) and helps motivate me (I don’t wanna do the dishes, but if I call a friend I’ll get Connection). It’s awesome.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Cobbe's avatar

Tried and failed to sort out some SQL joins. My SQL skills are like my Spanish. I can ask where the bathroom is and how long until dinner, and the rest is just me saying "Donde?" over and over.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Ha, I love that comparison. I hope the failures help illuminate the next steps to take!

Expand full comment
Eileen's avatar

I started a talk about web accessibility, and about how our conversations about it are so stunted because we forget/refuse to talk about the ableism in our work teams. It is far from done! But at least that outline file isn't empty anymore.

Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Brilliant!! I’m so, so glad this work is happening thanks to you!

Expand full comment
RMDCade's avatar

I hit a roadblock in the gay eldritch harp repair story I've been tinkering with, so this week has been largely devoted to going through things in my storage unit to organize it and winnow out the chaff. It counts as productivity! It's useful! So long as I keep telling myself that!

Expand full comment
Jshaden's avatar

This sounds like my work life. I’m a program manager in a field where the length of the overall projects often exceeds one’s tenure in a given position. But we passed a review for one portion of the effort this week. Getting used to not having a “deliverable” at regular intervals was the hardest thing about this type of work for me. Some days are just a string of meetings to decide what should get done by the next meeting. And I worked on a knitting project that will probably take a few more weeks to finish.

Expand full comment
Jackie Daggers's avatar

I didn't manage to finish the short story I've been working on. My goal was to be done today so I could reach out to an editor about cost to review the piece. I was able to get some other things done, I just ran out of spoons and hours for this one this week.

I also didn't succeed in finishing Seanan McGuire's Middlegame this week. That book is causing me such sorrow I can't pick it back up. It's so beautiful I'm dying to know what comes next but my heart is caught in the knot of yarn Middlegame is tugging at and trying to knit a sweater of angst from.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 10, 2020
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Amal El-Mohtar's avatar

Hooray for self-knowledge & steady progress! I had no idea you were working on a novel—I’m so excited for you! Is it in a similar realm as your sword expertise? Or something wildly different?

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 10, 2020
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Jackie Daggers's avatar

Craig I love the sound of this novel!

Expand full comment